NUTTER BUTTER® Chocolate Cream Pie

10  Ratings
  • 30 min prep
  • 3 hr 30 min total
  • Makes 8 servings.

NUTTER BUTTER® Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe


  • 24 NUTTER BUTTER Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, divided
  • 1/4 cup (1/2 stick) margarine or butter, melted
  • 24 marshmallows
  • 1/2 cup milk
  • 2 oz. semi-sweet baking chocolate, chopped
  • 1-1/2 cups heavy whipping cream, divided
  • 2 Tbsp. salted peanuts, chopped


  • Coarsely  chop 8 of the cookies; set aside. Finely crush remaining 16 cookies; mix with margarine. Place in 9-inch pie plate; press firmly onto bottom and up side of pie plate to form crust. Refrigerate until ready to use.
  • Place  marshmallows, milk and chocolate in medium saucepan; cook on low heat until marshmallows are completely melted and mixture is well blended, stirring frequently. Remove from heat; cool completely.
  • Beat  3/4 cup of the whipped cream in small bowl with electric mixer on high speed until stiff peaks form. Add to marshmallow mixture along with the chopped cookies; stir gently until well blended. Spoon into prepared crust. Refrigerate at least 3 hours. When ready to serve, beat remaining 3/4 cup whipped cream until stiff peaks form; spoon over pie. Sprinkle with peanuts. Store leftover pie in refrigerator.

Recipe Tips

Size-WiseA serving of this sweet treat goes a long way on chocolate flavor!

How to Easily Crush CookiesUse a blender or food processor to quickly and easily crush cookies.

SubstitutePrepare as directed, substituting 1/2 cup semi-sweet chocolate chunks for the chocolate.


Nutrition Information

Makes 8 servings.

Nutrition per serving:

    • Calories 460 
    • Total fat 26 g
    • Saturated fat 9 g
    • Cholesterol 35 mg
    • Sodium 290 mg
    • Carbohydrate 52 g
    • Dietary fiber 2 g
    • Total sugars 29 g
    •     Includes added sugars n/a
    • Protein 5 g
    • Vitamin A 10 %DV
    • Vitamin C 0 %DV
    • Vitamin D n/a
    • Calcium 6 %DV
    • Iron 8 %DV
    • Potassium n/a
    • n/a indicates that data is not available

This recipe features:

We are using cookies in order to facilitate your navigation. By continuing to navigate on this website or clicking on the close button you accept our policy regarding the usage of cookies. Read our Privacy Policy to learn more.